Chapter V of X · The Factory City

Nobody was evil. So who poisoned the river? Externalities, playable

Eight dye works, none of them wicked. Together they kill the fishers’ catch. Who should pay?

Play Chapter V free ▸ Chapter V of The Visible Hand: The Factory City

The idea

An externality is a cost (or benefit) of a trade that falls on someone outside it. The dye works and its customers strike a fair bargain, but the fishers downstream pay part of the price. Because nobody is charged for the harm, too much of it happens. Pigou (1920) proposed charging each polluter the harm it does: a Pigouvian tax. Then only the activities worth more than the damage they cause keep going. Coase (1960) asked whether the two sides could simply bargain. Hardin’s tragedy of the commons (1968) is the same logic applied to shared resources.

What you do in the game

Eight dye works upstream, fishers downstream. Nobody is evil, yet the river dies. Players try charging each works for the harm it does. It takes about 5–8 minutes, runs in any browser and needs no account.

Why it matters today

Carbon taxes, congestion charges and fishing quotas are all attempts to put the missing price back.

Think about it
  1. Nobody wanted to poison the river. So who is to blame?
  2. After the charge, which dye works kept running, and why those ones?
  3. Coase says the two sides could just bargain. Why might that fail here?
Try it yourself ▸

Sources the game cites: Pigou (1920); Coase (1960); Samuelson (1954); Hardin (1968). Teaching this? See the lesson plan for Chapter V.

More ideas you can play

The CampfirePareto improvement and Pareto efficiencyThe Villageallocation without prices: lotteries, queues and strategy-proofnessThe Market Townmarket-clearing prices and price ceilingsThe Trading Portadverse selection and the market for lemonsThe Town Hallthe Condorcet paradox, agenda setting and Arrow’s theoremThe Capitalauctions, bid shading and the Vickrey second-price auctionThe Economythe circular flow and the paradox of thriftThe Bank and the Mintbank runs, deposit insurance and central bank commitmentThe Handrules vs discretion, time inconsistency, the Lucas critique and AI government